Showing posts with label The Inspector Lynley Mysteries. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Inspector Lynley Mysteries. Show all posts

Friday, November 20, 2026

Lynley

There aren't many modern detectives that have so quickly joined the cannon of classic sleuths as Inspector Lynley. I think this is in no small part due to the magnificent casting of Nathaniel Parker and Sharon Small as Thomas Lynley and Barbara Havers. Over six seasons and twenty-four episodes we embraced these characters, warts and all. Sure Lynley wasn't blonde and the role of Helen Clyde was a revolving door of actresses, but it was still a classic. At least to me. In fact I strongly believe that the connection forged between Nathaniel Parker and Tommy Lynley is so strong that this is why he's never been able to find another leading role, and as most mystery lovers will agree, the less said about his Armand Gamache, the better. But then again, Louise Penny's creation seems bound for a purgatory of subpar adaptations. Even Alfred Molina couldn't save Gamache. So while I love The Inspector Lynley Mysteries I know there is a very vocal minority out there who don't think the series did the books justice. While the show adapted the first eleven books the next twelves episodes were original material to the show. Which meant that, should a revival or reboot ever be contemplated, there are eleven volumes to draw inspiration from, and perhaps they'd get it right that he's a blonde this time. Seriously, I don't know why critics are so fixated on Tommy's hair color. Oh, I bet there's a Reddit forum on this. Yep. There is. Why isn't he six foot and blonde!?! I'm so glad the book fanatics haven't let me down. The original Lynley adaptation is nearing on twenty years since the finale aired and I am kind of shocked it's been that long. Or as Dorothy Parker did say, "Time doth flit; oh shit." So many detective shows have been rebooted and reinterpreted over the years that even those that are sacred haven't been spared. Yes, I'm looking at you Kenneth Branagh, what facial hair horrors do you have in store for us next!?! Personally, my opinion on hearing the news that we were getting a new Lynley was, I hope the blonde faction gets their heart's desire and that it's modern and more inclusive. Well, Leo Suter isn't blonde...but Sofia Barclay is more inclusive. Also they were smart and only adapted stories that weren't a part of the original series. But for the first two episodes the show was just too generic and bland. Lynley was anodyne. These characters could have been called by any names they were so generic. It felt like any other bog standard procedural with the way overexposed Daniel Mays once again playing the incompetent cop in charge. He's literally played this role in three adaptations I've watched this year alone. Thankfully the third episode, "Careless in Red," started to right this ship and I can finally see the characters coming into their own. And this was all down to Lynley's exasperation. Leo Suter played that Lynley irritation to perfection. And then Sofia Barclay in the finale finally felt like Havers, equal parts caring and put upon. If this show is given a chance it could be good. It will never replace the original in my heart, but I at least now see the proof of concept that was missing from the front half of the season.

Older Posts Home